For obvious reasons, the subject of frugality has been very much on our minds lately. Now that we're facing our first full week without gainful employment, I thought it might be useful to describe our belt-tightening activities.
Our black belts in frugality didn't start last week, or last month, or last year. The foundation was laid way back in 1992 when Don and I gave up our well-paying city jobs and moved to a fixer-upper on four acres in southwestern Oregon. We went from a combined income of $70K (extremely decent for the time) to zip, zero, zilch, nada. Now that was an adjustment.
But we made it work and, needless to say, learned a lot.
As a financial exercise for our current belt-tightening, I looked up some budgeting advice, much of which involved creating spreadsheets for various categories. Almost all budgeting advice includes the need to be flexible (for when life throw you lemons) and the importance of tracking one's spending
One such article had some sensible advice, including splitting income between needs (50%), wants (30%), and savings (20%). Personally I'd drop that "wants" category by quite a bit, but then we're still in the adjustment phase, not maintenance phase.
This website listed 18 budgeting categories as follows:
• Housing (rent, mortgage, taxes, insurance, maintenance, HOA fees)
• Transportation (payments, gas, repairs, insurance, parking fees, registration, public transportation costs, etc.)
• Food (grocery costs, restaurant meals, take-out or delivery, coffee shop stops, alcohol, work lunches)
• Utilities (propane, electricity, water, cell phones, internet, trash)
• Medical/health care (insurance, prescriptions, eyeglasses, out-of-pocket costs)
• Additional insurance (life, disability, etc.)
• Taxes (state, federal)
• Education/childcare (N/A in our case)
• Debt payments (personal loans, student loans, credit cards)
• Retirement/savings (something, hopefully, we won't touch; but nor are we likely to be able to add to it for a while)
• Household items/supplies (cleaning supplies, paper goods, home decor, small appliances)
• Personal care (hair, nail, makeup, beauty items, massages, spa treatments)
• Clothing (including shoes, accessories, purses, backpacks, work clothing)
• Entertainment (gym memberships, cable TV, movies, events, bars, hobbies/crafts, streaming services)
• Travel (airfare, car rentals, tickets, hotels, souvenirs)
• Pets (food, medication, vet visits, accessories such as toys)
• Gifts/charitable giving (charity, church, holidays, special events such as birthdays, etc.)
• Miscellaneous (could include things like bank fees, "excessive personal spending," postage, etc.)
I've said it before: If we had to lose our major income stream, it couldn't have happened at a better time in our lives. However that's because we've spent years pre-positioning ourselves in some major, major ways.
Some of those major pre-positioning tactics include:
• Living in a low cost-of-living area. Most, though not all, rural areas fall into this category.
• Purchasing our home outright when we sold our last place. This decision meant we had to limit our options to what we could afford, which means our current home is not our "dream" home, but that's okay. We're in the process of making it into our dream home, and that's what counts.
• Years of whittling down expenses. Make no mistake, this takes practice; but the results can be astounding (as the budget analysis below will show).
• Purchasing in advance things we knew we would need. During times when money is less tight, buying up things you know you'll need not only fights against inflation, but provides a cushion when income drops. We don't have to buy coffee or tea, for example, because we have plenty. We bought a rototiller last fall (a very high-ticket item for us), and now it's ours whenever we need it. Remember when I bought a few extra pairs of prescription eyeglasses? Yeah, ask me how happy I am to have those in reserve (I am absolutely blind without my glasses). We pre-purchased building materials when we could afford it, so when it comes time to build a chicken coop, finish the garden infrastructure (including fencing and drip irrigation), construct a calf pen and milking stall, etc., the out-of-pocket expenses to complete these projects should be low.
• Getting out of debt. Oh heavens, the freedom that comes with being out of debt is indescribable. This isn't something that can be accomplished easily; but if you still have a dependable income, I recommend aggressively paying off debt as fast as humanly possible. And then – this is important – don't acquire more. It's one of the reasons we transitioned to an all-cash lifestyle so many years ago; it means we don't fill up our (single) credit card with frivolous purchases.
So anyway, this is how we handle the budget categories listed above:
• Housing (rent, mortgage, taxes, insurance, maintenance, HOA fees). We have no mortgage, and we budget for the two bills we'll get every December: property taxes and homeowner's insurance. Our property taxes went up (no surprise), and now we pay about $1000/year. Our homeowner's insurance nearly doubled to $2000/year. Since both these bills come due in December, we have time to save up for them.
• Transportation (payments, gas, repairs, insurance, parking fees, registration, public transportation costs, etc.). We own our older (used) cars outright, so insurance is low; however we often have to pay for repairs as a result of driving beaters. Since we work from home, we probably spend about $150/month on gasoline (driving to town for church, errands, etc.). Don did mention he plans to curtail those "quick trips" to the hardware store for this or that, and instead will plan and combine such trips with other errands to avoid using gas. This means we'll be more housebound, but we're homebodies anyway, so it's no biggee.
• Food (grocery costs, restaurant meals, take-out or delivery, coffee shop stops, alcohol, work lunches). Take-out or delivery food is unheard of in our area, so that's not even on our radar. We had been in the habit over the last couple years of enjoying a restaurant meal about once a month, so that stops. We don't frequent coffee shops, have work lunches, or buy alcohol. (Once my current box of chardonnay is gone, it's gone.) Our pantry is full, as is our chest freezer, so with the exception of fresh vegetables, our food expenses are low, especially if we cut back on frivolous things. Besides, this year we'll have a garden and fresh milk from our own cow.
• Utilities (propane, electricity, water, cell phones, internet, trash). We have no water or trash costs. Our water comes from our well, and our trash is covered by our property taxes (our area doesn't have pickups, but rather centralized dumpsters). Normally our electricity bill is about $110 a month, but it spikes to almost twice that in the winter, because we use a stock-tank heater to keep the livestock water ice-free. We don't have smart phones (just one "dumb phone" for roadside emergencies), and of course we have internet service. Bottom line, there isn't a lot we can cut from our utilities.
• Medical/health care (insurance, prescriptions, eyeglasses, out-of-pocket costs). This is probably the biggest question readers have about our frugal lifestyle. How do we handle health insurance? Don is now covered by Medicare, and I'm covered by Christian Healthcare Ministries (a medical sharing business). Our monthly out-of-pocket costs for both these programs comes to about $415 for the two of us. Neither of us are on any prescription medicines, except Don's low-dosage blood pressure medication, which costs about $200/year. We thank God that we're in good health.
• Additional insurance (life, disability, etc.). We have no additional insurance.
• Taxes (state, federal). We pay quarterly taxes since we're self-employed. I'm working on our taxes at present; what we pay in quarterlies may go down since we can document a large income drop.
• Education/childcare. Not applicable in our case.
• Debt payments (personal loans, student loans, credit cards). Not applicable in our case.
• Retirement/savings. Contributions to our retirement savings is obviously taking a hit, and hopefully we'll never be in a position where we have to tap into our retirement savings.
• Household items/supplies (cleaning supplies, paper goods, home decor, small appliances). Not applicable, especially when on a budget. We have enough cleaning supplies and toilet paper to last a while, and home decor isn't even on our radar.
• Personal care (hair, nail, makeup, beauty items, massages, spa treatments). Bwahahaha. Nope.
• Clothing (including shoes, accessories, purses, backpacks, work clothing). Again, nope. We have plenty of clothes and shoes. Besides, I hate clothes.
• Entertainment (gym memberships, cable TV, movies, events, bars, hobbies/crafts, streaming services). Not applicable in our case.
• Travel (airfare, car rentals, tickets, hotels, souvenirs). We travel very little, and will travel even less going forward. I haven't flown since 2019. Don and I took a couple of road trips last year, but that's not likely to happen this year. The one trip we do have budgeted this year is to drive down to southern California to visit my very elderly parents.
• Pets (food, medication, vet visits, accessories such as toys). We have a lot of dog food on hand, and of course we take Mr. Darcy to the vet when necessary. We'll also be needing some additional hay for the cows before long, which we'll purchase as needed. We are responsible for the pets and livestock under our care, and have no intention of neglecting them.
• Gifts/charitable giving (charity, church, holidays, special events such as birthdays, etc.). It was a tough decision, but we had to cut back on our charitable donations (church and other charities). We hope God understands. As for holidays and birthdays, etc., the only time we ever spend money for these events is at Christmas (and not much even then), so we'll see what this upcoming holiday is like.
• Miscellaneous (could include things like bank fees, "excessive personal spending," postage, etc.). We have no bank (or credit union, in our case) fees; "excessive personal spending" is out of the question; and we'll handle other miscellaneous expenses as they come up.
When we sat down for our "budget summit" after I got the news I was being laid off, we estimated our streamlined yearly expenses (including food, charitable giving, taxes, insurance, etc.) to be around $18K. We're confident we can bring in that amount through freelance writing, so at this point, we're optimistic we'll be able to continue.
As Don put it, our goal is to give ourselves bonus points for wherever we can cut costs. He's talking about taking me out for pizza on a Friday or Saturday night as a sort of last hurrah (we haven't been able to do this for years!), but then ... that's it. Future pizzas will be made at home.
So this explains our black belts in frugality. I welcome any thoughts on how we can cut more costs and trim our expenses even further.
Patrice, I am sure you & Don will be fine. You've been down and out before. Then you pulled yourself up by your bootstraps.
ReplyDeleteThe only thing I could think of was cooking ex baking more than one item at a time for a quick heat up of the next meal. I know your older daughter is cooking. With her work load that busy it might work for her as well.
Debbie in MA
Thanks for insight into the process, Patrice. Having been through a pair of layoffs and a relocation to a job that paid less, it is helpful to see how others go about this process.
ReplyDeleteLooking at your list, the only thing that immediately comes to mind is transport (e.g., your cars). If you are homebodies anyway the cost of fuel and repairs could drop; have you considered just moving to a single vehicle and pulling the other off insurance for the time being? In my experience, auto insurance is fairly expensive.
We are experimenting with a single vehicle currently in our new location. There is certainly a convenience factor involved, but it is rather manageable at the present time.
A big money saver would be driving less and combining trips. If you go to town every week for church, combine your regular shopping trips with that. My parents did that for years, just got what they needed after church. For bigger items that require a drive to a larger town, make a list of what is needed on a monthly basis, and do a once a month trip to get those supplies or if you can go longer between trips, go every couple months. If you have a Costco or other membership card, see if you really need it, oftentimes the savings doesn't equal the membership fee. I know you dislike online shopping, but you can oftentimes save a lot of money by ordering stuff on Amazon or Temu and having it delivered as opposed to driving into town, it is beneficial to have a credit card of some type not tied to your actual bank account for that sort of shopping, but if you pay it off right away, no big deal. When you need to save money, sometimes you have to shop places you don't normally shop to save money.
ReplyDeleteYou did say you don't spend much on gifts, you may consider just cutting all gifts in general, even on Christmas. I was raised in a gift giving household, but prefer not to waste money on gifts for holidays. Or if you give gifts, stick with necessary things that can be used in the household or homemade personalized things. Personally I think gift giving at Christmas takes away from the religious aspect of the holiday, so we do more for birthdays instead, and nothing extravagant.
And not relevant for you as you don't watch TV, but for those who do like to watch movies and TV, if you need a new TV and have internet, get a cheap TV that includes Roku on it, you can watch tons of shows and movies for free, including many old classic shows and movies, saves a lot of money on streaming, if people already pay for streaming services.
Thanks for the good points.
ReplyDeleteSomething I would suggest doing every two or three years is to get insurance quotes on both home and auto - changing companies may reduce your costs for the same coverage.
Also, compare insurance costs versus out of pocket costs: a couple of years ago I dropped my auto deductible from $2000 per incident to $500 because it cost $20 more per year. It would take decades without an accident to make up the difference - and given how people drive, I'm not going to assume that will happen!
On the flip side, consider long term costs as well as short term. For example, full coverage costs me $250 a year, but it means that I'm covered no matter what happens and that if an accident is someone else's fault, my insurance company fights for me. In the long run it saves me thousands of I need to replace a car due to an accident.
(And if you do have an accident, don't be afraid to push back on their appraisal of your car - the only time I've totalled a car, my pushback got them to increase my payout by $3000).
Don't just look at short term costs - consider the long term too.
Jonathan
Not much to add or comment on because ya'll have done a good job covering everything.
ReplyDeleteUnder housing you didn't mention maintenance. For me that's a booger bear in this old house. Even with Don's handyman skills there will probably be some expense there, but I'm assuming you have savings. Hopefully nothing outside of the box will happen.
Maybe before next winter check into a solar tank heater. That may be a cost savings investment on utilities if it works out.
I'm a decade older than ya'll, and have found in the last few years that in spite of healthy eating, things were going wrong with my health. Aging changes things.I felt I wasn't getting something in my diet or my body wasn't getting nutrition to where it was needed. I started supplementing over time and have had reductions in pain, gained back some flexibility, and a laundry list of complaints aren't so front and center of my life anymore. Still working on it. I started with Qunol magnesium because it's the absorbable kind, and D3 and K2. These helped, but more things were needed. I won't go into everything, but found as I researched problems I had and addressed them with diet changes and more supplements they improved or resolved. I am mentioning this because it isn't cheap, but it positively changed over time the aging process. It is something to plan for.
There is one person on youtube who gets the lion's share of credit for my success educating myself on various health issues, thouh he isn't the only one. It's Dr. Eric Berg. His video's are concise and to the point and he uses a white board to teach the basics of lots of health issues. For free. He does sell supplements, and I have wound up buying some, but not just his. Gotta keep a watch on the bottom line, but as far as information goes, he does the best job in my opinion. So if you ever want to research some symptom or health issue he has hundreds of informative videos.
Health is so important. I'm hoping some insurance starts covering more natural, healthy options than just pharmaceuticals. I think that is something RFK Jr. Is interested in. If a doctor could prescribe the magnesium and D3 K2 and have insurance pay for that sort of thing as preventive care it woild be awesome. Do think about adding supplements possibly to expected healthcare expenses in the future. They make a big difference.
I have been following you for years. I am sorry you lost your position. Genesis is hiring for part-time remote positions. I think you would be qualified. Go to info@isgenesishistory.com.
ReplyDeleteThankfully, you and Don are on the same page. I know you guys “got this” but I will add you to my regular prayer list. When you get back to an income you would prefer, considering socking away either additional savings or a portion for “home disaster”. We just went through that, again. For us it was hurricane/tropical storm damage and we don’t even live right on the coast. Yours could be weather/fire related, burst pipes, or even septic/sewer breakdown. Both times we thought insurance would kick in. Nope! We didn’t have a separate “home disaster” fund but fortunately had enough in savings to cover the repair bill.
ReplyDeleteI have a few things to share about how I manage money. First. when I went on Medicare, I chose a traditional medicare supplement that had no annual deduction or co-pays. I pay more per month for this plan then some of my friends pay for their plans. But, I can plan for that monthly expense. I also chose a supplement that would bridge the gap between what Medicare would pay and what the healthcare provider actually charged. Again, should I need medical care, I don't want any surprises. As a bonus, the supplement gives me a quarterly $100 for over the counter items such as toothpaste and vitamin supplements. The list is quite extensive.
ReplyDeleteYou didn't mention discounts. My local grocery store allows customers to take a 'survey' once a month. The prize for taking the survey is a code good for 5% off most anything on one shopping trip. I use that code once a month without fail. Yes, I have to play the game and be part of their loyalty program. I chose to belong. YMMV.
I also do not have any streaming services for entertainment with one exception. I pay for Amazon Prime which gives me free shipping on orders as well as access to TV shows and movies. In almost two years using this service, I have not felt the need to add on any streaming services. Since I'm a solid 20 minutes away from any large store, I feel like the Prime membership pays for itself in gas savings.
I had a good chuckle about your reaction to 'personal beauty products'. I have to say my dog is also getting home care treatments as well. I invested in a good set of hair clippers and nail clippers. BTW, during the Cvid of 2020, I gave myself some home hair cuts using those clippers as well. Short but hey, the hair grew eventually and I wasn't going anywhere at the time.
I know you and Don are great at penny pinching and will do well in this new chapter of life. I'd like to think I'm helping in some oh-so-very small way by using your Affiliate link when I order on Amazon.
Cheering you on, SJ now in California
One car is enough when you do not commute. Apparently you have several?
ReplyDeleteAlso having heater on cows watertank is unnecessary. Just give them lukewarm water when you add water, it takes ages for water to freeze. Also cows bodies produce incredible amount of heat, it should keep cow barn on +-degrees even if it is -20 degrees (Celcius) outside. If the barn is any good, that is. People (and cows) did just fine millenia before electricity was invented.
Your online employer has been going downhill for quite some time. Their over the top support of "our greatest ally" since last year has taken the "cake". They have basically LOST all of their mojo. Based on your columns for the past 20+ years, you should weather this "storm". I wish you and Don the very best. You can try to post insightful items on brighteon.io. God Bless, Patrice.
ReplyDeletem