Saturday, May 30, 2020

The novel frugality

Over the last few weeks, I've been collecting stories about something that's being termed the "Novel Frugality." Apparently – no surprise – the concept of thriftiness is being abruptly introduced to a whole lot of people who previously paid it no mind.

"We're trained to buy often, buy cheap, and buy a lot," observes a woman named Anne Helen Petersen in a piece called "I Don't Feel Like Buying Stuff Anymore." "And I'm not just talking about food, which everyone has to acquire in some capacity, or clothes. I mean all the other small purchases of daily life: a new face lotion, a houseplant holder, a wine glass name trinket, an office supply organizer, a vegetable spiralizer, a cute set of hand towels, a pair of nicer sunglasses, a pair of sports sunglasses, a pair of throwaway sunglasses. The stuff, in other words, that you don't even know that you want until it somehow finds its way to your cart at Target or T.J. Maxx."

While people like Ms. Petersen may find themselves astonished at their sudden desire to be frugal, my thought is something along the lines of, "Welcome to the club." I don't mean that in a snarky way, either; I mean it quite seriously. Welcome.

I'm a huge advocate of frugality. It is a powerful fiscal weapon. In fact, arguably it's one of the most powerful weapons in anyone's financial arsenal.

We were forced into a frugal lifestyle back in 1993 when we left California (and our two well-paying jobs) and moved to Oregon, where we found ourselves without paid employment. Until our woodcraft business got off the ground, we had to be very careful of our spending. We had no choice. After our woodcraft business got off the ground, we kept up that level of frugality because we preferred saving money rather than spending it.

We nipped here and tucked there. We trimmed this and cut that. Little by little, step by step, we brought our spending in line with our income, whatever that income was at the time. Sometimes our income was more, at which time we spent more. Sometime it was less, at which time we tightened our belts.

This has been our way of life for nearly 30 years now, so it's second nature. I think that's why I derive some amusement from articles purporting to be shocked when people actually line-dry their clothes and forego restaurant meals.

But then I remember, that used to be us. Frugality is a learned skill, just like anything else.

In one article entitled "The Novel Frugality: After decades of materialism, some Americans are experimenting with thriftiness for the first time" (warning, some bad language), writer Meredith Haggerty examines the rise of the disposable consumer culture and the falling away of the thrifty legacy from the Great Depression. "In this environment," Haggerty writes, "the remaining [frugal] holdouts have often been laughed at, ignored, and little studied, but they haven't disappeared."

Apparently frugality can be separated into two types: intrinsic and extrinsic. This means frugality can be voluntarily adopted (intrinsic) or involuntarily imposed (extrinsic). What isn't discussed is how frequently extrinsic frugality can lead to intrinsic frugality. In other words, how often does involuntary frugality (imposed by poverty) result in the ability to regain control of one's finances, after which voluntary frugality allows one's standard of living to rise? We started off in one category, and it allowed us to move to the other category.

Even if their finances are not immediately threatened, a lot of people are responding to the pandemic by acting as if resources will become scarce. Accordingly, they're washing and reusing their Ziploc bags and using bread heels to make croutons, while joking they're "turning into their grandma." Reasons range from concerns about the supply chain to a reluctance to jostle among crowds at the supermarket.

[As an aside, Haggerty's article also has the obligatory warning about when frugality becomes hoarding. For whatever reason, these two positions are linked in a lot of peoples' minds. To this end, Haggerty quotes a social worker and author named Elaine Birchall as follows: "She [Birchall] helps clients, before and now, work through how to persevere, to trust that there will be enough. Birchall's own household found itself down to one roll of toilet paper ("because I do not hoard") but, just as she tells her clients, the universe provided and she was able to buy more before it became a problem."

Um, the universe provided? What a stoopid explanation. At first I was inclined to be charitable toward this piece – after all, a lot of people have no experience with frugality – but then the whole "hoarders" association and "the universe" nonsense put me entirely off. Okay, back to the main point.]

But enough about this first article. In another article I read shortly thereafter entitled "How a $500 Monthly Allowance Saved Our Marriage," the author reports on her financial hang-ups and insecurity from the trauma of growing up with a breadwinning father and a stay-at-home mother. (The horror, I know.)

This writer (Catherine Baab-Muguira) reports that only by instituting a $500/month allowance for discretionary spending – in which she and her husband can each spend that sum on whatever they want, no questions asked – was she able to save her marriage. "I am so wary of dependence that the merest suggestion makes me break out in hives," Baab-Muguira writes. "I have to feel that I am independent or I cannot be married, as much as I love Chris."

It sounds like Baab-Muguira and her husband are financially responsible people ("Since we adopted the system, we've paid off all our student debt, opened a joint brokerage account, and even bought a modest house"), but I do wonder how either or both would adapt if they lost their income or were forced into frugality due to present circumstances. Would Baab-Muguira's marriage survive? I sincerely hope so.

Meanwhile, according to an older (2009) New York Times article, it seems Don and I fall under a category called the "gleefully frugal." This oddball subset "happily seeks new ways to economize and takes pride in outsaving the Joneses. The mantra is cut, cut, cut – magazine and cable subscriptions, credit cards, fancy coffee drinks and your own hair." The article references people who darn socks, air-dry clothes ("even though it takes a few days for the clothes to dry inside"), wash and reuse plastic bags, and employ other thrifty practices that apparently baffled the writer.

The bottom line on all these "Novel Frugality" articles are what Don and I learned years ago: You can either EARN MORE or you can SPEND LESS. We chose to SPEND LESS so we could keep homesteading. But at the time we chose to SPEND LESS, it was just that – a choice. Now a huge number of people are being forced to SPEND LESS because the choice to EARN MORE is no longer there.

What I hope is this Novel Frugality can be seen as liberating, not traumatizing. If you're used to an affluent lifestyle, then yeah, it's a difficult adjustment. But living low can be amazingly freeing (no more worrying what the Joneses think!).

And it truly does become second nature. I'm always startled whenever someone tells us they went out to eat at such-and-such a restaurant. Why would they spend the money? Ditto with purchasing clothes, especially new clothes. Why spend the money, when thrift stores have everything you need?

In the field of behavioral economics, there's a theory called "loss aversion" which suggests that once we get used to a certain level of luxury in our lives, we find it almost impossible to give up, and doing so feels like deprivation. Therefore for whatever luxury you enjoy and would feel deprived without, find a frugal workaround and give yourself permission to enjoy the results.

The goal in frugality is balance. It does no good to cut expenses to the bone if you're sullen and resentful the whole way. Instead, find what luxuries you don't want to cut, and find frugal alternatives.

Above all, frugality is not deprivation or a penance; it's deliverance. Deliverance from debt or from a lifestyle you long to escape. Frugality and thrift have allowed endless people to escape circumstances they didn't like and pursue the changes they wanted.

For those engaging in the Novel Frugality, I'll say it again: Welcome.


  1. Thank for the article Patrice.

    I find both amusing and ridiculous that we have to now define and categorize "frugality". I think this reflects our current age, when everything has to be touched by the modern world in order for it to be accepted. Can we just accept something as it is without having to define it for ourselves?

  2. I can tell you why I like to eat out occasionally: someone else fixes the meal and someone else cleans up. That is a luxury that I enjoy once in a while.

  3. I have a problem with folks calling someone who has spent their money preparing their pantry for uncertain times a "hoarder". They have chosen to spend their money on "stuff" while I have chosen differently. If I have 100 rolls of toilet paper I purchased BEFORE the pandemic, they still believe I am a hoarder. Of course people on my Christmas gift list this year will be receiving food or hygiene gifts they don't have enough of. Appreciated the article and I'll be glad to see young folks and even older ones begin to be frugal again.

    1. I too have plenty of everything on hand at all times, and have been called a hoarder. My grandparents on both sides lived through the depression and always had big gardens and canned the produce. It was normal to have a closet full of food on hand. I consider myself prepared for a crisis such as an earthquake. We are told to have 3 days of food on hand. Only three days? It could take weeks or months to get supplies back to normal. What has gone on the last few weeks should show us that-and we didn't have major infrastructure damage. I am mystified that everyone doesn't have a few cans of soup and a bag of rice on hand. By thinking ahead, everything can be bought on sale. When my adult children complained they couldn't afford to be like me, I told them to just buy one extra thing each time they shop. It really adds up and is not even really noticeable to the budget. I was baffled at the TP shortage earlier this year. Who waits to be down to only a few sheets in the house? I had plenty on hand and still haven't purchased any in 2020.

  4. I am nowhere near as frugal as I should be to say the least. I am also one of those who is blessed (or cursed).,by the same income every month and every year barring the generosity of the cost of living gods ( the upside or downside of being a military/ federal employment family). But I am a stocker upper even in single e
    Widowhood and I am extremely tired of hearing basic stocking up or emergency preparedness compared to hoarding. Drives me nuts.....

  5. You're right on target. The "experts" don't have a clue. In a forever unpublished book I just finished, the main character passes his hereditary attitude on to his children: "The power of money lies in not spending it, because what you have saved then prevents you from being forced into bad decisions."

  6. Awesome article, Patrice! When I hear in the news that folks don't have TP, Lysol spray, Ivory soap, other essentials etc and are stampeding stores to get them, I wonder: "What were you doing without basics in the home?"

    I am also not in line for the free food being given away by churches (God bless 'em!) because I always buy large quantities when things are on sale.

    Some where along the way, I forgot to keep extra butter in the freezer, and had to pay FULL PRICE to keep from feeling butter-deprived....I nearly fainted at the cost.

    And I have no garden, no animals, no productive hens...I'm just a regular old retiree who knows how to pinch a penny.....always have, always will!

  7. Patrice, have you heard about the effort to recall Gov Little? Details available here:
    A blog post on this would be awesome!

  8. My wife used to consume (and I mean that literally) hoarder tv shows. Then, my frugality became an issue. I think there is a tendency in this day and age to psychoanalyze everything to death. And if you find something you don't understand, then there is a psychosis you can blame it on, and feel superior to the one you "diagnosed". Or maybe exert control over their behaviour because you watched tv and are now an expert.

    1. STxAR, I give your comment a BIG thumbs up! (luckily, my DH is on board with my 'ways' d/t weather and life events we've dealt with over the past 10 or so years).


  9. When my husband was little, his Mother went grocery shopping every 6 months; yup, not weeks, months; twice a year. So she bought a lot at once, then didn't have to go until the next half year. I had a point in my life where I had no money and had to eat 6 for a dollar ramen noodles, so I lived plenty and almost nothing. Now, we are pretty well stocked up even living in an apartment(though I haven't gotten to the point of only twice a year shopping). It helps to be ready for any potential lean times!